About Anthony's Stamps & Coins

Anthony's Stamps & Coins is a family-rooted buyer of coins, stamps, paper currency, and collectibles, founded in 1958 and based in Englewood Cliffs, New Jersey. Rather than running a storefront, the company sends its buyers to the customer's home, office, bank, or safe deposit box, reviews the entire collection in person, and pays in full on the spot, so nothing has to be packed or shipped. It buys complete collections, estates, accumulations, sets, gold and silver, and certified coins, and serves collectors, families, attorneys, and estates across the Northeast, Mid-Atlantic, and Midwest. Anthony's is a PCGS and NGC authorized dealer, an ANA member, and an active eBay seller since 1997 with more than 121,000 positive feedback ratings.

Challenge

Most of the people Anthony's wants to reach are not collectors. They are heirs and executors who have just inherited a closet full of albums and have no idea what any of it is worth, and they are wary of buyers who cherry-pick the best pieces or ask them to ship valuables to a stranger. The company's decades of history, dealer credentials, and eBay track record were its strongest proof, but its web presence did not put that proof in front of a nervous first-time seller or explain how a visit works. Every lead is a call or a form, so that step had to feel easy. SmartSites set out to design and build a website that answers a seller's doubts and turns them into inquiries.

How we helped Anthony's Stamps & Coins.

Website Design

SmartSites builds a trust-first website for coin & stamp collection buyers

SmartSites designed and built a new website for Anthony's Stamps & Coins that reassures inherited-collection sellers and walks them from first question to an in-person visit.

  • Design & UX: Built a black and gold design with close-up coin and album photography, a trust band of 1958, eBay, and feedback numbers, and dealer credentials near the top of the page.
  • Conversion flow: Placed Tell Us About Your Collection and Call 800-488-3515 buttons in the header, hero, and every section, ending in a collection inquiry form.
  • Content: Added a four-step how-it-works section, a we-come-to-you map of the states served, a consign-versus-sell comparison table, an inherited-collection section, and an FAQ.
  • Service pages: Launched pages for selling a coin collection, certified PCGS and NGC coins, and dozens of coin series, plus state pages for the areas served and a blog of selling guides.
astampcoin.com
Anthony's Stamps & Coins homepage on desktop
Anthony's Stamps & Coins homepage on a phone
  • WordPress Platform
  • Click-to-call Tell-us-about-your-collection form
The new site gives an unsure heir every reason to pick up the phone before the collection ever leaves the house.

Marketing that brings in more shoppers.

We’ll find where your next shoppers are coming from, and build the plan to bring them in.

On a free call, we’ll:

  • Show you which competitors win the shoppers you want, and why.
  • Find the quickest wins in search, ads and your website.
  • Give you a plan, a budget and the results to expect.
  • Clutch Top Retail Marketing Company 2026
  • The Manifest Top Retail Digital Marketing Company
  • GoodFirms Top Web Design Company
  • Best SEO Services 2025 by Forbes Advisor
  • Inc. 5000 honoree, 10 years
Danielle Denman Connor O’Hanlon Zach Everett

Let’s grow your store together.

Get a free proposal from the team behind $2.1 billion+ in client revenue.

"*" indicates required fields

This field is for validation purposes and should be left unchanged.
What services are you interested in?

We reply within one business day.