Website Builder vs. Freelancer vs. Digital Agency

When you are deciding how to get your first website built, a website builder is the natural first choice for many small businesses. Builders are inexpensive, easy to use and can get a site online quickly if you can put in the time. Medium to large businesses often find that builders do not offer enough functionality or support. They are willing to invest in a reliable, well-equipped website that works as a marketing tool and actively reaches new, targeted customers, not just a static brochure.

Before you choose between a website builder, a freelancer and a digital agency, decide what your company needs from a website in the first place. Your goals for designing and developing a website should drive the decision.

Decide what your website must do before you choose who builds it

At its simplest, a website is an online brochure with your products or services and contact details. If you run a small family auto repair shop, a neighborhood store or a farm stand, where most customers meet you face to face anyway, a brochure site that drives people to your location may be all you need. But what will bring people to the site to begin with? Most people use search engines such as Google or Bing. That is where search engine optimization (SEO) comes in. At a minimum, you want your website to be set up so that it can appear near the top of results for the searches that matter to your business.

Some companies do business both online and offline, selling products on the website and in a shop. A bakery, for example, might take cake orders and payment online, with pickup when the cake is ready. Accepting payment online makes buying easier for customers, who can order from anywhere, and it helps your cash flow because you are paid before you spend on ingredients. Pre-orders work the same way for businesses that import or custom-produce items. A site that can handle e-commerce transactions can support a healthy bottom line.

And you do not have to stop there. A modern e-commerce website can cross-sell and upsell, offer promo codes and free-shipping thresholds, remind customers about items left in their carts and support retargeting ads. You can also reach new customers with landing pages and free guides that collect email addresses, so you can market to people who have shown interest. With a full-featured website, the marketing possibilities are nearly limitless.

With those possibilities in mind, here are your options for building your site.

Website builders are fast and affordable, with limits

Entry-level website builders are inexpensive and easy enough that there is little excuse for not having a website. Builders such as Wix and Squarespace bundle hosting with extras like a domain name, SSL security and customer support. Most now also offer AI tools that draft a site from a few answers about your business. If you want more control, you can take a modular approach with WordPress, which you install on your own hosting.

What are the main differences between Wix, Squarespace and WordPress? Here is a closer look.

Wix suits beginners who want creative control

Wix is a drag-and-drop builder aimed at a broad audience. You can start for free, but professional features such as a custom domain name, e-commerce and removal of Wix branding need a paid plan. It offers many templates for almost any type of business, and you will not touch a line of code. For tech beginners who want some creative control, it is a good option.

The limitations show up when you want to change things later. Switching templates after your site is live has historically been restricted, so check the current rules before you commit. And if you want to grow, you may end up adding third-party apps that you have to research and choose yourself, which can be overwhelming for a beginner.

Squarespace rewards design-minded owners who can handle a learning curve

Squarespace is also a drag-and-drop builder, but it uses a section-based system rather than letting you place elements anywhere. That takes a bit of learning, and for many people it is worth it. Squarespace sites tend to look polished and design-forward, and the platform offers a free trial before you pay. It has fewer add-ons than Wix’s app store, but the ones it includes work well with its templates, so functionality is solid from the start.

The main limitation is the time it takes to learn the platform, so it is not the best choice if you want a site up in a few hours. AI-assisted setup tools from Squarespace and other builders now shorten that first draft, but you will still want to review and refine the result.

WordPress gives you the most flexibility and needs the most upkeep

There are two ways to use WordPress: a hosted plan on WordPress.com, or self-hosting the software from WordPress.org on your own web host.

WordPress.com works much like a website builder, with a streamlined interface and no code required, and you can pay for extra features as you need them. WordPress.org is free software you install yourself. It is the most customizable option, but it is easier to run with some technical help.

WordPress began as a blogging tool and is now a full content management system. That is good news if you plan to publish a blog or lots of pages, but it does mean there is more to learn about how pages, posts and the block editor work compared with a drag-and-drop builder.

If that sounds daunting, consider how many sites use it. WordPress powers a very large share of the web, by some counts more than 40 percent of all websites, so many businesses have decided it is worth the learning curve. As more companies move toward content marketing, which calls for a blog anyway, starting on WordPress can save you trouble later. The tradeoff is maintenance: you need to keep WordPress, themes and plugins updated and fix issues that come up. If you are not willing to do that, or pay someone who will, this option may not suit you.

In summary, here are the pros and cons of using website builders:

159% Increase in site trafficImmigration Law Firm Drives Site Traffic by 159%See the case study →

482% Increase in leadsNJ Podiatry Practice Expands Lead Volume by 6xSee the case study →

A freelancer costs less but carries more risk

If you want a site that is more robust and flexible than a builder allows, but you do not have the time or technical know-how to build it yourself, you can outsource the job to a freelancer or, with a larger budget, a digital agency.

Freelance web designers are self-employed and have no company overhead such as office space and utilities, so they tend to cost less than agencies. Other benefits include one point of contact, direct communication with the person building your site, and often a fast turnaround, since they are paid when the work is done.

The downside is risk. There are plenty of stories about freelancers who took a deposit and disappeared. Quality assurance can also be thin. If something breaks, or a technical SEO problem appears, you may have to pay the same freelancer, or a new one, to fix it. Even highly rated freelancers can miss critical details, such as leaving a site blocked to search engines with robots.txt. Ask for examples of past work, references and a clear written scope before you pay.

A digital agency delivers quality and expertise at a higher price

When you work with a digital agency, you are working with a registered business that has a reputation to protect, so it is unlikely to vanish midway through your project. Agencies usually work as teams, with specialists handling design, development, content and SEO, rather than one person doing everything.

The benefit is dependable quality. A solid team and a proven process mean you can count on the results. With specialists working on your project, your website can look good, communicate clearly and be built to convert visitors into leads.

The main reason businesses hesitate is cost. For the best results, expect to pay more than you would for a builder or a freelancer. Then again, a website that works hard to bring in traffic and customers can cost less over time than a cheaper site that nobody sees and that never converts. Agencies can also take longer, because several teams and quality checks are involved.

Finally, read the contract carefully. Some agencies charge monthly fees and never hand over ownership of your website, which ties you to them. When you hire an agency, confirm that you will own your site, your domain and your content, and that there is no hidden monthly lock-in.

Ask these questions before you sign with anyone

Whichever route you take, a few questions protect you from the most common problems:

Who will own the website, the domain name and the content when the project ends?
What does the price include, and what costs extra, such as hosting, updates and support?
How will the site be set up for search engines, and who checks it before launch?
Is the site responsive and fast on phones, and can you edit it yourself afterward?
What happens if something breaks after launch, and who fixes it?

Match the option to your budget, timeline and goals

There are many ways to get a website built, and the right choice depends on your budget, timeline, working style and goals. Startups may want to use a website builder to keep early costs low. A freelancer can be a good fit if they have a proven track record and you trust them. A digital agency can give you the best product and quality for a higher upfront cost that can pay for itself over time. Choose based on your situation and your needs.

If you decide to hire a digital agency, SmartSites has been recognized by DesignRush and other directories as one of the top agencies in New Jersey: